Essential Interview Questions for Hiring Supervisors: A Guide for Employers and HR Leaders

Essential Interview Questions for Hiring Supervisors: A Guide for Employers and HR Leaders
Interview with Supervisor

Selecting the right supervisor for your team is about more than filling a vacancy; it’s about choosing a leader who will foster growth and positivity within your team. At the same time, understanding the true potential of candidates beyond their resumes can be challenging.

This guide is meant to help you navigate this process. We’ve compiled a set of interview questions that are designed to uncover the qualities of a good supervisor, their skills, and how well they align with your company culture. Consider this guide as a key tool for identifying the ideal supervisor who will fit with your team.

As you read on you’ll find questions aimed at uncovering a candidate’s approach to leadership, conflict resolution, team motivation, and cultural fit. We also explore how candidates adapt to change and manage team performance. The goal is to make your interview process an effective strategy for discovering the best supervisor for your team.

Hiring supervisors? ERC’s Supervisory Training helps supervisors and managers learn essential skills for the job. Flexible in-classroom or virtual options are available.

Types of Questions

When interviewing potential supervisors, you should consider a diverse range of question types to comprehensively evaluate a candidate’s fit for the role.

Behavioral questions are a staple in this context, as they provide insight into how a candidate has handled specific situations in the past. These questions often reveal patterns in behavior, decision-making, and problem-solving abilities — essential skills for a supervisory position.

The STAR method, an acronym for Situation, Task, Action, and Result, is a structured approach used in behavioral interview questioning. By encouraging interviewees to outline a specific situation, describe the task they needed to accomplish, detail the actions they took, and share the results of those actions, employers can gain deeper insights into a candidate’s past experiences and problem-solving abilities.

Situational questions, on the other hand, present hypothetical scenarios to assess how a candidate might react in future circumstances. They help gauge a candidate’s critical thinking and adaptability.

Experience-based questions delve into a candidate’s previous roles and achievements, providing a picture of their professional journey and the depth of their expertise. This type of questioning helps understand the scope and scale of their past responsibilities, shedding light on their readiness for the supervisor role.

Skills-based questions focus on specific competencies required for the job, such as team management, communication skills, and technical know-how. These questions are essential to determine if a candidate possesses the necessary skills to perform the job effectively.

In addition to these question types, key interview topics should also include:

  • Motivations and Career Goals — Understanding what drives a candidate and where they see themselves in the future can align their ambitions with your company’s objectives.
  • Leadership and Management — Questions about leadership and management are crucial to understanding a candidate’s approach to leading a team, making decisions, and handling challenges.
  • Self-Development — These questions help reveal a candidate’s commitment to personal growth and adaptability to change, indicating their potential for long-term success.
  • Culture Fit — These questions ensure a candidate shares your organization’s values and can seamlessly integrate into the team, contributing positively to the workplace environment.
Supervisor in manufacturing setting

Common Interview Questions for Supervisors

Finding the right supervisor for your team starts with asking the right questions. In this section, we’ve put together some of the most common interview questions for supervisors, all aimed at helping you get to the core of each candidate’s leadership skills, problem-solving abilities, and how well they’ll fit into your team’s culture.

Can you describe your previous experience in a supervisory role?This question aims to understand the depth and relevance of a candidate’s supervisory experience, focusing on their practical experience in similar positions.
What were your primary responsibilities in your previous role?By asking this, you’re looking to understand the scope and scale of a candidate’s previous supervisory duties (if any) and how they align with the current role’s requirements.
How has your experience prepared you for this position?This question is designed to understand how a candidate’s past experiences have equipped them with the skills and knowledge necessary for the position they are currently interviewing for.
What are your salary expectations for this supervisory role?This question helps gauge whether a candidate’s salary expectations align with the budget and compensation structure of the organization.
How would you describe your management style?This question will help you understand a candidate’s approach to managing teams, including their methods for motivating, guiding, and assessing team members.
Why should we hire you?Asking “Why should we hire you?” in an interview can be beneficial as it encourages candidates to communicate their unique values and align their skills and experiences with the job requirements.On the other hand, the question can also be overly generic, potentially leading to rehearsed responses that offer limited insight into a candidate’s genuine fit for the role.
What is your greatest strength/weakness?Asking candidates about their greatest strengths and weaknesses can provide insights into their self-awareness and honesty, as well as how they perceive their abilities relative to the job’s demands.But again, this question is quite common and might prompt rehearsed or overly polished responses, potentially limiting your ability to get a real understanding of a candidate’s true capabilities and areas for development.

Role-Specific Supervisor Interview Questions

When interviewing candidates for a supervisory role, it’s important to ask questions that directly relate to the demands and responsibilities of the position. In this section, we’ll explore role-specific questions that will help you gauge a candidate’s suitability, key skills, and understanding related to the supervisory role in your organization.

Skills Related to Supervisory Roles

Asking about specific skills during the interview process allows you to delve deeply into whether candidates possess the essential competencies needed to excel as a supervisor.

How would you describe your communication style, and can you give an example of how it has been effective in a supervisory role?This question seeks to understand a candidate’s communication skills and how they adapt their style to be effective in leadership.
Can you provide an example of a situation where your leadership skills made a significant impact on your team’s performance?This aims to assess a candidate’s leadership skills and their direct influence on team outcomes.
Describe a time when you had to use your interpersonal skills to resolve a conflict within your team.This question is designed to evaluate a candidate’s conflict resolution abilities and their interpersonal skills in managing team dynamics.
Tell me about a complex problem you faced in your previous supervisory role and how you solved it.Here, you’re looking to gauge a candidate’s problem-solving skills and their approach to tackling challenging situations.
In your experience as a supervisor, how have you demonstrated strong supervisory skills in day-to-day operations?This question aims to understand the practical application of a candidate’s supervisory skills in managing everyday tasks and team interactions.
Can you discuss a time when your management skills directly contributed to improving your team’s overall performance?This is designed to assess the impact of a candidate’s management skills on enhancing team efficiency and productivity.
How do you ensure compliance with employment laws and promote diversity and inclusion within your team?The purpose of this question is to evaluate a candidate’s awareness of employment laws and their commitment to fostering a diverse and inclusive work environment.
Describe how you manage your time and prioritize tasks in a fast-paced role.This question seeks to understand a candidate’s time management skills and their ability to effectively juggle multiple responsibilities.
Can you give an example of how your critical thinking skills have helped you make a strategic decision?You’re looking to evaluate how a candidate uses critical thinking skills to make informed, strategic decisions in their role.
How do you approach managing and improving employee performance in your role as a supervisor?This question is intended to evaluate a candidate’s employee performance management skills, focusing on how they monitor, assess, and enhance their team members’ performance to align with organizational goals.
Meeting with 3 employees

Team Management and Leadership Questions

Exploring a candidate’s approach to team management and leadership through specific interview questions helps shed light on their ability to guide, inspire, and drive a team towards success, a cornerstone of effective supervision.

How would you address and improve the situation of an underperforming team?This question aims to understand a candidate’s approach to identifying issues within a team and their strategies for enhancing overall team performance.
Can you give an example of how you’ve managed underperforming employees in the past?You’re looking to gauge a candidate’s ability to effectively handle individuals who are not meeting performance expectations, and their methods to motivate and support these employees.
What strategies do you/would you employ to build an effective team?This question seeks insight into a candidate’s experience of team building and their techniques for assembling a cohesive and productive team.
How do you/would you structure regular team meetings to ensure they are effective and engaging?This question aims to assess a candidate’s skills in organizing and conducting regular team meetings that are purposeful and beneficial to team dynamics and goals.
Describe your experience leading or working with a cross-functional team. What were the challenges and how did you overcome them?Here, you’re trying to understand a candidate’s ability to manage or work with a diverse team with different skill sets and how they navigate the unique challenges that arise in such settings.
As a leader, how do you/would you assess and boost team morale?This question is designed to evaluate a candidate’s awareness and strategies for maintaining and improving team morale, a key component of a healthy work environment.
Can you share an experience where you had to align your team’s goals with changing organizational objectives?You’re trying to understand how a candidate ensures team performance aligns with the evolving goals of the organization, reflecting their adaptability and leadership skills.

Creating and Maintaining a Positive Work Environment

Asking potential supervisors how they would create and maintain a positive work environment helps determine their capability to foster a healthy, engaging, and productive workplace, crucial for team morale and success.

How do you/would you create and maintain a positive work environment for your team?This question aims to understand a candidate’s strategies and actions to foster a workplace that is upbeat, supportive, and conducive to high morale and productivity.
Can you give an example of how you’ve contributed to building an inclusive work environment in the past?You’re inquiring about a candidate’s commitment and approach to inclusivity, ensuring that all team members feel valued and supported.
Describe a time when you successfully fostered a collaborative work environment. What strategies did you use?This question is designed to assess how a candidate encourages teamwork and collaboration, creating a culture where ideas and contributions are shared openly.
In a fast-paced environment, how do you ensure your team remains positive and motivated?You want to understand a candidate’s ability to maintain a positive atmosphere in a high-pressure, dynamic work setting, crucial for team resilience and success.
What measures do you take to ensure your team’s work environment stays collaborative?This question seeks to uncover a candidate’s tactics for preserving a collaborative environment even under stressful or challenging circumstances, ensuring continued teamwork and problem-solving.

Dealing with Specific Situations

Asking questions about how a potential supervisor would handle challenging on-the-job situations provides insights into their problem-solving abilities, resilience, and capacity to maintain effective leadership under pressure.

Describe a challenging situation you faced and how you managed it.This question seeks to understand a candidate’s problem-solving approach and resilience when dealing with difficult and unexpected challenges in a supervisory role.
Tell me about a time when you had to handle a difficult situation involving another employee. How did you address it?You’re aiming to assess a candidate’s interpersonal skills and their ability to navigate sensitive or contentious issues with tact and professionalism.
Can you recall a particularly stressful situation in your previous role and how you maintained your composure?This question is designed to evaluate how a candidate manages their stress and maintains a calm, effective leadership presence under pressure.
Describe a complex situation you encountered and the steps you took to resolve it.You want to understand a candidate’s critical thinking and decision-making skills in handling multifaceted issues that require a strategic approach.
Give an example of a real-life situation where you had to quickly adapt your strategy or plan. What was the outcome?This question aims to assess a candidate’s adaptability and quick thinking in response to rapidly changing circumstances, a key skill for effective supervision.

Self-Development and Personal Motivation Questions

Exploring a potential supervisor’s approach to continuous development not only sheds light on their commitment to personal and professional growth but also reveals their underlying motivations and long-term vision for the role.

How do you approach continuous development and learning?This question aims to understand a candidate’s commitment to self-improvement and staying updated with industry best practices, which is crucial for effective leadership.
Can you share your career goals and how they align with the organizational goals of this role?You’re seeking to understand whether a candidate’s career aspirations are in sync with the company’s objectives, ensuring a mutually beneficial relationship.
Describe how you have set and achieved goals in your past positions.This question is designed to assess a candidate’s ability to establish, pursue, and accomplish specific and tangible goals within an operational context.
What motivates you to achieve a common goal with your team?You want to understand a candidate’s driving forces for teamwork and collective achievement, which is key to successful supervision.
How have you taken advantage of professional growth opportunities in your previous roles?This question aims to uncover a candidate’s proactive approach to personal and professional development, and how they leverage growth opportunities for career advancement.
Can you describe a time when you had to adapt your skills to meet new challenges or changes?You’re looking to evaluate a candidate’s adaptability and willingness to grow and evolve in response to new challenges, a critical aspect of ongoing professional development.
Employee in the workplace

Cultural Fit Questions

Assessing a candidate’s cultural fit ensures alignment with the organization’s values, a key factor of their potential to thrive and contribute in the workplace.

How do you define a strong candidate for a supervisory role in terms of organizational culture?This question aims to understand a candidate’s perception of a good fit within the company’s culture, revealing their alignment with the organization’s core values and work environment.
Can you provide an example of how you’ve aligned a team with company values in a previous role?You’re looking to assess how a candidate integrates and promotes company values in their leadership and team management practices.
Describe a situation where you had to adapt to a significantly different organizational culture. How did you manage the transition?This question seeks to evaluate a candidate’s adaptability and approach to embracing and integrating into a new organizational culture.
How do you see our company values aligning with your personal values and work style?You want to understand how a candidate’s personal values and professional approach coincide with the company’s established culture and ethos.
What aspects of our organizational culture attracted you to this position and how do you envision contributing to it?This question is designed to gauge a candidate’s genuine interest in the company’s culture and their intent to actively contribute to and enhance it.


The hiring process for a supervisor position involves more than just assessing qualifications; it’s a deep dive into finding an ideal candidate who can truly lead and inspire a team.

The job interview questions we’ve presented in this guide are tailored to help you evaluate each candidate’s suitability for the role. The right questions should help you evaluate an individual’s leadership qualities, ability to navigate complex situations, and alignment with your organization’s culture.

By using the right questions, you can improve your hiring process, ensuring that the supervisor you choose is not only skilled but also an ideal match for your team’s dynamics and your company’s long-term objectives.